“Babes in Toyland” (1903) and “The Red Mill” (1906) are about as American as you’d find on the musical stage at that time, which is to say that they’re very German even as they ape the then-popular French operettas that were so successful in England. The nicely recorded Naxos CD offers two suites, proving how thoroughly Herbert’s catchy tunes insinuated themselves into the musical language. We know them as folk tunes, and when “March of the Toys” wraps up the “Toyland” suite, we’re comfortably back in a childhood state of mind.
But that’s not to overlook his evocative “Mississippi Suite” from 1926, which carries us through the heartland of America and ends up at a Mardi Gras celebration in New Orleans. The orchestra is spared no pomposity, but the work grows on you. “Niagara Falls Suite” was commissioned by the New York State Power Authority, and Grofé conducted its first performance in 1961 with the Buffalo Philharmonic. The musical language is denser and more complex, but the effects are every bit as startling and evocative as in his other works. Conductor William Stromberg has been featured in a number of Naxos film score releases, and proves himself just as able with these scores; likewise, Sousa specialist Keith Brion’s conducting shines on the Herbert CD. Both deserve Naxos’s “American Classics” designation.
Grofé: Orchestral Works
Bournemouth Symphony Orch., William T. Stromberg, cond.
Herbert: Babes in Toyland/The Red Mill
Razumovsky Symphony Orch., Keith Brion, cond.
– Metroland Magazine, 17 June 1999